Kidney Transplant or Not?
Reported April 01, 2010
(Ivanhoe Newswire) — A new clinical prediction index has been developed to determine the risk of death in kidney patients considering transplantation.
A new study seeks to develop and test a new index that can calculate survival for various options faced by a patient with end-stage kidney disease. It included patients on the kidney transplant wait list between 1995 and October 2006 as well as those who had a kidney transplant during the same time.
As the index uses readily available data, it can be used in clinics during transplantation counseling. It has a simple scoring system to calculate survival without transplant, with deceased donor transplantation and with living donor transplantation. The goal is to improve decision making by patients and physicians by providing calculated survival information at the time of transplant counseling.
Kidney transplant is the optimal choice for people with end-stage kidney disease. In addition to improved quality of life and survival rates, kidney transplant recipients have a 68 percent lower risk of death than those eligible for transplantation who remained on dialysis.
While the benefits of transplantation are significant, there is a need to look at other factors before proceeding, including quality of life after transplantation, immunosuppressive medication side effects, malignancy risk and the need for an extensive medical evaluation or ongoing re-evaluation.
Dr. Carl van Walraven and coauthors wrote that this prognostic index can accurately predict mortality among patients with end stage renal disease eligible for transplantation.
“We believe that this renal prognostic index can provide valuable quantitative survival data for clinicians and patients to use when deciding on whether to pursue transplantation or remain on dialysis,” Dr. van Walraven was quoted as saying.
SOURCE: Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ), March 29, 2010