TORONTO - The percentage of injection drug users from Vancouver's
Downtown Eastside neighbourhood found to be carrying a worrisome superbug jumped
250 per cent from 2000 to 2006, a new study reveals.
The rise was fuelled by spread of a worrying strain of methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus, or MRSA, which has been causing soaring rates of
community-acquired infections in the United States, reported the researchers,
who are from Vancouver Coastal Health and the University of British Columbia.
Experts called the rapid increase startling and suggested it could be a
harbinger of what is in store for the wider population as this nasty
drug-resistant bug makes its way through Canadian communities.
"I think what this says is: We've got a genetically very smart microorganism
here," said senior author Dr. Elizabeth Bryce, a medical microbiologist and
infection control specialist with Vancouver General Hospital. "And these
(injection drug users) could be the canaries in the coal mine."
Dr. Andrew Simor, chief microbiologist at Toronto's Sunnybrook Health Centre,
agreed.
"This article just documents what's happened in Vancouver, but it also true in
other Canadian centres," said Simor.
"Calgary in Alberta. And we are certainly seeing an increase in Toronto, in
Montreal, in London, Ont., and many other communities across the country."
The study, published in the February issue of the Journal of Clinical
Microbiology, compared MRSA colonization rates over time in injection drug
users, a group known to be at higher risk of both carrying the bacteria and
developing infections triggered by it. Other high risk groups are residents of
First Nations' reserves, athletes who play team sports and prison inmates.
Bryce and her colleagues found that in 2006, 18.6 per cent of 300 injection drug
users tested were carrying MRSA, a steep and surprising rise from the 7.4 per
cent shown to be "colonized" with the drug-resistant form of the bacteria in
2000.
"This is certainly one of the highest colonization rates I've seen," said Dr.
Elizabeth Bancroft, a medical epidemiologist with the public health department
of Los Angeles County, which for years has been battling what is now considered
an endemic MRSA problem.
Staph bacteria are ubiquitous. Between 25 and 30 per cent of healthy people
carry Staph in their nose or on their skin at any given time. Some will go on to
develop Staph infections - often boils or skin lesions, but sometimes
life-threatening bloodstream infections or pneumonia.
The proportion of people carrying the drug-resistant form of the bacteria is
substantially smaller. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control estimate in that
country, about one per cent of people are colonized with drug-resistant strains.
MRSA colonization rates haven't been calculated for Canada but "I'm sure it
would be even lower," Simor said. (Neither Simor nor Bancroft were involved in
the Vancouver study.)
But rather than take comfort from Canada's lower rates, infectious diseases
experts in this country are worried. Simor and others believe the MRSA profile
here is shifting to become more in line with that of the United States, where
invasive MRSA infections are estimated to have caused nearly 19,000 deaths in
2005.
"It's not just a phenomenon south of the border. It is occurring in Canada. It's
established itself here. And the problem is likely to continue to grow unless we
are successful with a concerted infection control and public health response,"
he said.
What concerns public health experts on both sides of the border is the spread of
MRSA outside of the walls of hospitals, where the drug-resistant strains were
historically found. The combination of sick people and abundant antibiotic use
makes hospitals a fertile breeding ground for MRSA and other superbugs.
But in the last decade or so it has become apparent new strains of MRSA have
arisen and are circulating outside of hospitals. Alarmingly, they were causing
infections in healthy people who hadn't been hospitalized and hadn't been on
antibiotics - in short, people who previously wouldn't have been considered at
risk of developing MRSA infections.
In the U.S., much of the community-acquired disease is caused by a
drug-resistant Staph strain known as USA-300.
That is the strain Bryce and her colleagues found so commonly among the
Vancouver injection drug users.
When the initial testing was done in 2000, none of those who were colonized
carried the USA-300 strain. Instead, they were colonized with a strain known as
USA-500, a strain generally found in hospitals.
By 2006, only a quarter of the colonized drug users carried USA-500 bacteria.
The remaining 75 per cent were carrying the USA-300 strain. Bancroft found the
overwhelming shift surprising.
"What was remarkable to me is not only did the rate of people with MRSA just
jump up, but almost the entire increase was due to the so-called USA-300 strain
coming into this population and then sort of spreading," she said.
While this particular strain most commonly causes skin and soft tissue
infections, it can cause severe illnesses. In February 2006, for instance, a
previously healthy 17-year-old boy from Scarborough, Ont., died from an MRSA-triggered
pneumonia.
"It can cause extremely nasty stuff," Bancroft said. "It can cause anything from
something that's a self-limited decent size pimple all the way to death. It can
cause a full range of outcomes."
Frequent hand-washing is the best known protection against Staph bacteria and
both Bancroft and Simor suggested public education programs getting out that
message would help to control spread.
Bryce suggested public health authorities in this country should do studies to
get a handle on how much MRSA there is outside of hospitals, so they know what
they are dealing with.
"I think we know fairly well what's in the hospitals. The community is a big
question mark. And if you know what's in the community and what groups are at
risk and now much CMRSA (community-acquired MRSA) is in the healthy population .
. . that will help you target your interventions."
Source : Canadian Press